James Duncan Davidson on the Aperture 1.5 Color Control
2006-10-05
James Duncan Davidson comments on his blog about the new color control in Aperture 1.5 (just the top half shown):
and compares it to the one in Lightroom, now, ahem, Photoshop Lightroom:
I agree with what he says. However, he omits one major problem with the Lightroom tool: when a person goes to adjust colors they do it one color at a time; but the Lightroom tool is organized by attribute first and then color second. So to adjust one color you must jump about between the sections, hoping you don't click the wrong slider in error. Aperture gets this right and provides the color attribute controls for each color next to that color and does so using a cleaner layout.
and compares it to the one in Lightroom, now, ahem, Photoshop Lightroom:
I agree with what he says. However, he omits one major problem with the Lightroom tool: when a person goes to adjust colors they do it one color at a time; but the Lightroom tool is organized by attribute first and then color second. So to adjust one color you must jump about between the sections, hoping you don't click the wrong slider in error. Aperture gets this right and provides the color attribute controls for each color next to that color and does so using a cleaner layout.
The Bagelturf site welcomes Donations of any size